The Gift of the Magi

Compare and contrast Jim and Della’s characters.

How does the presumed setting (New York in the early 20th century) affect the characters and the plot of the story?

Why does the author spend so much time describing Della’s thoughts and experiences while we only get to know Jim toward the end of the story?

Both characters seem discontent with their material status in the story. Their apartment is described as small, and their clothing seems worn. But are Della and Jim living in poverty, or are they just unhappy with their social status?

What could have prevented Jim and Della from selling their most prized possessions?

Describe your interpretation of the ending. Is it endearing that both characters give up their prized possession to buy a gift for each other or frustrating because neither character can enjoy the other’s gift?

Do Jim and Della’s gifts indicate that they are truly in love, or not? Explain your answer.

Do you agree with the narrator’s closing words: “Of all who give gifts, these two were the most wise?” Why or why not?